[JFresh] Je trouve extrêmement idiot que la question pour le trophée Hart semble souvent être « l’équipe aurait-elle fait les séries éliminatoires sans ce joueur? » selon cette norme, hudson fasching devrait être un concurrent Hart
i find it extremely silly that the question for the Hart Trophy seems to often be "would the team have made the playoffs if it weren't for this player?"
by that standard, hudson fasching should be a Hart contender
— JFresh (@JFreshHockey) April 17, 2023
—
Tniz15
6 Comments
Faschists rise!
Fasching for the Hart!
https://youtu.be/ihyOpGg1k-8 Immediately reminded me of this
But… Hudson Fasching should arguably be a Hart finalist
While we’re at it Matt Martin for the Lady Byng
I think it would be silly to make that the only qualifier, just as it would be silly to make any single metric the lone qualifier.
I don’t think it’s silly to take it into consideration along with everything else, though. If it comes down to a handful of similarly skilled/rated players, why shouldn’t it matter if one of them made a larger impact on their teams success?
Isn’t that a big part of what « value » is?
The Hart trophy is literally “the player most valuable to their team”. The Oilers would be a lottery team if not for McDavid. He’s far and away the best player every year, let alone a world class season this year specifically.
Brock Nelson is more important to this team than a 3rd or 4th liner. I get Fasching has been solid and clutch, but let’s not fall into overrating our own bottom 6-ers again. Remember last year when the Islanders fan base lost their shit when we released Austin Czarnick?