Il avait évidemment une longévité folle et une grande distribution autour de lui, étant ainsi le leader de tous les temps en matière de victoires. Mais il n’a pas de Conn Smythes, n’a remporté aucun Vezinas jusqu’à ce que Hasek quitte Buffalo et n’a jamais remporté le Hart. Pour moi, il est difficile de justifier de mettre Marty sur Hasek ou Roy. je dis 3eme
—
InkAddict718
47 Comments
Goat there is literally new paint on the ice because of him. His play literally changed the rules that’s how good he was.
Modern era…#1
Probably 3, behind Roy and Hasek
#2 behind you know who.
Just my opinion, but Brodeur should have won the Conn Smythe in 2003. 7 SOs, including 3 in the Finals.
#2 behind Hasek
1st
#2 behind Roy
He’s definitely on my Mt. Rushmore of goalies. Patrick Roy, Dominik Hasek, and Jacques Plante are there too.
Very, very high.
#2 behind Roy.
Top 5 because they’re all pretty interchangeable. Hasek, Roy, Brodeur, Plante, Sawchuck, Bower, Price… the list is big but I’d argue that Brodeur, Hasek, Roy could win or lose you games. But having any of those guys back there would give you enough confidence to take risks.
Number 1 his stats are higher than Roy over a longer career and Hasek has better stats but played 547 less games
Brodeur
GP:1266 SO:125 GAA:2.24 W:691 L:397 T:154 PCT:0.912
Roy
GP:1029 SO:66 GAA:2.54 W:551 L:315 T:131 PCT:0.910
Hasek
GP:719 SO:81 GAA:2.20 W:389 L:223 T:95 PCT:0.922
Number 1. I also live in jersey and was in my late teens when he played so I may be biased.
Just behind Ron Hextall
To me, he’s the greatest evolutionary player in the position. Statistically, the best. His exceptional butterfly combined with amazing puck movement on the Devils with a heavy trap made him invincible.
Contrast that with Patrick Roy who basically transformed the game with the butterfly, but who has inferior numbers. I think they’re both 1A/1B in goalies all time.
Found Sean Avery’s reddit account
SA called him ‘fatso’ 🤣
Top 3 – All-time
Top 5 for me. As a Flyers fan, he was always killing us.
S tier and it’s too tight between those guys
Marty has almost every record, a trio of cups, and radically changed the sport while being more traditional than most of his peers
Stats wise Hasek is the clear #1 especially when you account his teams
Top 3.
Everyone will have different opinions on the order but IMO the system NJ played inflated Brodeurs numbers somewhat so we can’t only look at that to make the decision.
Roy and Hasek lead inferior teams to Cup wins or at least to the finals.
All three are great!
Top 2. And he’s not number 2.
(Yes, I’m biased, I know)
Top 3 with Hasek and Roy.
Number 1 is a tough question.
It’s wild to think Brodeur, Roy, and Hasek were contemporaries.
Better question….how many cups did he win without Scott Stevens???
Top 2 are Hasek and Roy, then there are about 4 or 5 different goalies you could make a case for to be 3rd and he is in that group.
Well Hasek is clear cut number 1 ever. No debating that.
I dunno about brodeur. Top 5 maybe
1. Hasek
2. Roy
3. Brodeur
1. Hasek
2. Roy
3. Brodeur
Hasek’s peak was the best of all time IMO. Roy was the more talented goalie between him and Brodeur, Brodeur benefitted *more* from the team he played for and their system.
Greatest of all time… At handling the puck behind the net, overrated system goalie.
In the top 3 with Hasek and Roy. I think picking the top 3 from there is all debatable and super close regardless.
IMO, he’s #3
1. Roy
2. Hasek
3. Brodeur
Now, let’s reflect what a fucking time to be a hockey (goalie) fan that era was.
When my Avs played the Devils/Brodeur, I was always confident we’d come out on top. When we played Hasek, I was scared.
Certainly Top 3 imo, alongside Roy and Hasek
Uno
Way up there
He is the top goalie of all time
7th
There is a clear demarcation in hockey history where the goaltending changed for the better. That is 1984 with Patrick Roy. Once his style of playing the position caught on, it became incrementally more difficult to score.
Hasek is an outlier due to his incredibly unorthodox style.
Brodeur was one of many all-star caliber goalies that played in the 90s through 00s that played a very solid butterfly hybrid style. Broduer gets the nod ahead of the likes of Belfour, Richter, Joseph, etc. for a few reasons, elite puck handling skills, longevity, and the NJ defense first, neutral zone trap teams he played on.
That’s my 1, 2 ,3.
You can’t really compare goalies from 70s, 60s, and 50s. Because then you are bringing in Dryden, Parent, Cheever, Plante, Bower, etc. to the conversation, and that just mucks it up even more.
He’s top 5. Probably top 3 but I never saw some of those older goalies play.
Brodeur was the best I’ve ever seen at reading the play. He wouldn’t just automatically butterfly, but adjust to the shot with his hybrid style. He made so many plays become “one and done” attempts. Everybody gave his stick handling and defense all the love, but didn’t realize it all revolves around this ability. His skating was also miles better than Roy or Hasek.
He’d aim rebounds TO his defenseman all the time. He’d stay on his skates and randomly knock down a puck and easily clear it out of the zone instead of letting it hit his chest and drop down to freeze it. Over time this led to his incredible durability. He was beyond elite at essentially negating dangerous time in the Devils defensive zone before it ever got started.
The other thing is he usually gets the backhanded compliment that he was good but had a good team in front of him. Nobody ever seems to mention he always left money on the table so he always HAD a good team in front of him.
Right up there. Great goalie. Granted he played for a very defensive, trapping team but he’s good make no mistake. (Rangers fan here)
Definite top 5.
Love me some Hasek, but it’s Brodeur, and then Roy. Brodeur has every single significant goaltending record, including Sawchuk’s shutouts that was considered to be unbreakable. I have a book published in 1989 that stated just that.
3rd
Brodeur scored the most goals.
Dryden and Hasek are 1 & 2. I’m happy with either one in either slot. There’s not another goalie I’d trade one of these two for.
Roy is my number 3.
4-10 is a handful of goalies which includes Brodeur.
Mid point of the top 10 for sure. He was an amazing goalie no doubt.
Part of the problem is how do you compare old goalies to new?