Ducks by a mile and trust me I’m totally unbiased on this
Medschoolmonkee
Wildwing eats that Gordon fisherman for breakfast
UopuV7
Angler for the design, ducks for the color
captainseagull8
I like the islanders the fisherman with the hockey stick is cool
roofratMI
I’m digging the Islanders
mkhop97
Ducks for sure
Yung_Corneliois
Ducks colors scheme gives it the win but both are gorgeous.
Professional_Entry40
Ducks.
Honestly both these jerseys are nostalgic gems to me. I understand the hate they get (both logos are cartoony, the jerseys use unusual and asymmetrical striping, nontraditional color schemes) but aesthetics are fundamentally subjective and these gave both teams, but especially the Ducks, a stronger visual identity than they have now. The Islanders at least have history and a classic hockey look to draw on for their jerseys, the current Ducks logo and jerseys are boring, with the exception of the orange one using the old logo.
bearamongus19
Ducks
buckyhermit
Islanders.
Ironic, given my flair. lol
DeplorableKurt
Ducks
naked_avenger
I think the Islanders one looks better, but the cultural significance of the Ducks one makes it what I would wear. I have no attachment to the Islanders.
0bl1v10n204
Mighty ducks for sure! So much nostalgia there from the movies as a kid
The_Next_Wild_GM
Ducks, but only due to personal nostalgia. IMO, those ate the best sweaters the Ducks have had
TiredReader87
The Mighty Duck
Deliriousdrew
Sigh…the Ducks
coronetgemini
might ducks is iconic… islanders angler I am just learning about now.
CraftierAverage
Due to them being my team growing up from the cartoon to the mighty duck movies. Hands down duckies. Only thing better is the wild wing alternate of him boomin through the ice.
quickshot56
Is this even a question? The Ducks by a landslide. Flying V forever.
ChapelHeel66
Ducks
ImWicked39
The ducks. I’m biased.
Edit: I honestly love both.
Birdhairs
Ducks for sure but this is my first time seeing this islanders jersey and I dig it
MemoryNeat7381
Quack quack quack
N0B3L
The Islanders one looks better
DefeaterOfDragons
Islanders
FormerCollegeDJ
The Islanders’ mid-1990s jersey isn’t called “Angler”; it’s called “Gorton’s fisherman”.
ItsTheExtreme
I always liked these islanders sweaters. How were they received when they first came out? I remember the Gordon fisherman stuff but did fans hate them?
The_EVP
The Fishsticks jersey will always be the best one! This Islander fan will gladly take the Fishsticks name & wear it with pride!
jokerj4513
Islanders 100%
touchdown604
Islanders! No comparison
ATastyPickle
There must be a lot of bias here because those angler jerseys are sick. Love me a Mighty Ducks throwback jersey though
ImmediateBar915
Love both.
phxcm42069
isles
GreatIceGrizzly
I know people felt it floundered, but I always like the Captain High Liner version of the Islanders jersey…
36 Comments
Ducks
Ducks
Ducks by a mile and trust me I’m totally unbiased on this
Wildwing eats that Gordon fisherman for breakfast
Angler for the design, ducks for the color
I like the islanders the fisherman with the hockey stick is cool
I’m digging the Islanders
Ducks for sure
Ducks colors scheme gives it the win but both are gorgeous.
Ducks.
Honestly both these jerseys are nostalgic gems to me. I understand the hate they get (both logos are cartoony, the jerseys use unusual and asymmetrical striping, nontraditional color schemes) but aesthetics are fundamentally subjective and these gave both teams, but especially the Ducks, a stronger visual identity than they have now. The Islanders at least have history and a classic hockey look to draw on for their jerseys, the current Ducks logo and jerseys are boring, with the exception of the orange one using the old logo.
Ducks
Islanders.
Ironic, given my flair. lol
Ducks
I think the Islanders one looks better, but the cultural significance of the Ducks one makes it what I would wear. I have no attachment to the Islanders.
Mighty ducks for sure! So much nostalgia there from the movies as a kid
Ducks, but only due to personal nostalgia. IMO, those ate the best sweaters the Ducks have had
The Mighty Duck
Sigh…the Ducks
might ducks is iconic… islanders angler I am just learning about now.
Due to them being my team growing up from the cartoon to the mighty duck movies. Hands down duckies. Only thing better is the wild wing alternate of him boomin through the ice.
Is this even a question? The Ducks by a landslide. Flying V forever.
Ducks
The ducks. I’m biased.
Edit: I honestly love both.
Ducks for sure but this is my first time seeing this islanders jersey and I dig it
Quack quack quack
The Islanders one looks better
Islanders
The Islanders’ mid-1990s jersey isn’t called “Angler”; it’s called “Gorton’s fisherman”.
I always liked these islanders sweaters. How were they received when they first came out? I remember the Gordon fisherman stuff but did fans hate them?
The Fishsticks jersey will always be the best one! This Islander fan will gladly take the Fishsticks name & wear it with pride!
Islanders 100%
Islanders! No comparison
There must be a lot of bias here because those angler jerseys are sick. Love me a Mighty Ducks throwback jersey though
Love both.
isles
I know people felt it floundered, but I always like the Captain High Liner version of the Islanders jersey…