Thornton isn’t even close to a top 10 player. He’s probably not even be a top 50 player in all honesty.
GeneralPip
No
epanek
Bossy was better than Thornton
peaceandloved
Thornton? Didn’t see that.
JustinRansom
No
therealphoodie
McDavid is already at 414 and we’re less than halfway through the decade 🤯
AceConspirator
Definitely not, no. He’s probably not top 25 either.
kylemclaren7
No lmao. End of replies
tour79
80s Gretz is almost more than any other 2 decades combined
JKolodne
Hard to believe Ovechkin or Crosby didn’t have more than Kane
yosoyboi
Jumbo Joe is top 50. Certainly not top 10 though.
No_Bread7614
No
ass_smacktivist
All time top 10 Dman yes. All time top 10 player? No. And this is coming from someone who is biased.
MIDImunk
To OP’s question – Absolutely not
Merkkin
Nah
who987
No
Professional_Entry40
Nah man, but he sure was fun to watch for a while there. Seems like a decent enough feller too.
IdyllicOleander
Two Hawks up there!
LET’S FUCKIN GOOOOO!!!
SiidChawsby
No. Why even ask?
Roberto_Sacamano
Gretsky’s stats never cease to amaze me
WeAreAllFooked
Not even remotely close.
baker1781
If you take away every point scored by Gretzky in The 90s, he’d still be top 3 all time.
jimhabfan
No, and before you ask, neither is Kane.
mud_dragon
It’s crazy we are only in 2023
petridish21
Definitely not. Love him but he’s probably not even top 50.
Salt-Test7577
Napoleon Dynamite just found his new Stanley Cup partner!
ryguy8105
No, definitely not top 10 all time, but the NHL keeping him off their top 100 players of all time list is absolutely ridiculous
Electric-Lettuce
What a stupid question
QueefyBeefMeat
Sweet McJesus we still have 7 more seasons this decade to watch the Man himself
Ordinary-Pirate2869
Nope, not even close.
LegalComplaint
There are as many Blackhawks as there are Gretzkys on this…
PRMan99
If you don’t have at least 2-3 Cups, how can you even be in the conversation? Great players win.
rudecanuck
No? This is not a hard question to answer.
​
Lemieux, Gretzky, Orr, Crosby, Jagr, Howe, Hull, Sakic, Forsberg, Roy, Hasek, Brodeur (yes, the infamous Goalie run), Ovechkin (yuck), Lindros (another Yuck), Espiosito, McDavid, and even Kane….All definitely better than Thornton. Those are really without question. And we only have 1 Defencemen in there! Include Coffey, Lidstrom, Neidermeyer, Pronger, and he drops even more.
HE was an awesome playmaker though.\
​
ALSO, yes, my Penguins fandom biases how I list the players above.
47 Comments
Nope
No
Gretzky really fell off on the ’90’s. Pathetic
McDavid at 414 points already is insane
There’s only three players on that graphic that are top 10 all time. Big Joe ain’t one of them. Not exactly close either.
Thorton without the beard looks like Napoleon Dynamite
Unfortunate timing for Crosby. Comes in mid decade, loses tons of games to injury the next decade. Is still putting up whopping numbers at age 35.
[deleted]
Lol
If jumbo joe scored the next 3 overtime game 7 cup winning goals in a row he still wouldn’t be top 10 all time.
[Joe Thornton is not top 10. ](https://youtu.be/s3dZP3io-xc)
no
Jonathan Cheechoo thinks he is.
Lmao gretz
Thornton isn’t even close to a top 10 player. He’s probably not even be a top 50 player in all honesty.
No
Bossy was better than Thornton
Thornton? Didn’t see that.
No
McDavid is already at 414 and we’re less than halfway through the decade 🤯
Definitely not, no. He’s probably not top 25 either.
No lmao. End of replies
80s Gretz is almost more than any other 2 decades combined
Hard to believe Ovechkin or Crosby didn’t have more than Kane
Jumbo Joe is top 50. Certainly not top 10 though.
No
All time top 10 Dman yes. All time top 10 player? No. And this is coming from someone who is biased.
To OP’s question – Absolutely not
Nah
No
Nah man, but he sure was fun to watch for a while there. Seems like a decent enough feller too.
Two Hawks up there!
LET’S FUCKIN GOOOOO!!!
No. Why even ask?
Gretsky’s stats never cease to amaze me
Not even remotely close.
If you take away every point scored by Gretzky in The 90s, he’d still be top 3 all time.
No, and before you ask, neither is Kane.
It’s crazy we are only in 2023
Definitely not. Love him but he’s probably not even top 50.
Napoleon Dynamite just found his new Stanley Cup partner!
No, definitely not top 10 all time, but the NHL keeping him off their top 100 players of all time list is absolutely ridiculous
What a stupid question
Sweet McJesus we still have 7 more seasons this decade to watch the Man himself
Nope, not even close.
There are as many Blackhawks as there are Gretzkys on this…
If you don’t have at least 2-3 Cups, how can you even be in the conversation? Great players win.
No? This is not a hard question to answer.
​
Lemieux, Gretzky, Orr, Crosby, Jagr, Howe, Hull, Sakic, Forsberg, Roy, Hasek, Brodeur (yes, the infamous Goalie run), Ovechkin (yuck), Lindros (another Yuck), Espiosito, McDavid, and even Kane….All definitely better than Thornton. Those are really without question. And we only have 1 Defencemen in there! Include Coffey, Lidstrom, Neidermeyer, Pronger, and he drops even more.
HE was an awesome playmaker though.\
​
ALSO, yes, my Penguins fandom biases how I list the players above.