Surprised they think EK65 is 3 overall worse then Josi after just winning the Norris and putting up 100 points
anivoflean
slavin too low as usual
LoneIyGuy
Carlson and Hedman little too high
Showaren_elle
Miro is too low
GoldWhale
Charlie Mac > Fox…? Okay?
jamaicancovfefe
I’d have Sanderson over Chabot, but either way it’s awesome to see a Sen in the top 10 of something
bajubiejunior
Interesting choice there with Carlson
brady_t12
Carlson is a bit high here lol. Maybe an 88 due to his offensive capabilities but he’s awful defensively.
nothing_but_static
I still want Toews back
SquirrelShepherd
Bunch of geeks trying to rank athletes. Hit the gym, dorks
HashBrown72
Hampus Lindholm better
Kilroy60
Charlie Mac best in the game
OttawaFisherman
Chabot is wayyyyy to high. He’s the third best defenceman on Ottawa
ckncardnblue
I’ll take Petro. Not much he can’t do when it’s playoff time.
sadolddrunk
I haven’t played a hockey videogame in almost 20 years, so I apologize if this is a stupid question, but: why the differentiation between left and right defensemen? Does the game treat them as if they are totally different positions? Like you can’t pair Karlsson and Letang up because they’re both right defensemen?
JackManningNHL
Fascinating, but Theodore lines up on the right more than he lines up on the left.
spssky
Has Josi had a late career resurgence? Obviously he was always good, but the last 2-3 seem to be a second peak for him
-cyg-nus-
Devon Toews not being on this list is absolutely stupid.
Edit: still not used to this shit official reddit app. The little dots indicating a second photo are fucking tiny. I see it now. The lime green eye cancer background doesn’t help either.
Finrad-Felagund
Disrespect to Miro is very very very real.
Captain_Naps
These are always good for a chuckle.
OlympicMuffins
Seider has had a great start to his career but 88 already is a bit much
ryanb6321
I’m sorry but I think Roman Josi gets overrated a lot. Like he’s no doubt a #1 defenseman but I don’t think he’s ahead of a lot of these guys under him. I’d give him a 90 instead of a 94.
Felixeur
Chabot is lowkey overrated by EA and I am a Sens Fan. Sanderson is just better or tied with Chabby imo
BCLetsRide69
Roman Josi is NOT that good holy cow
Chaotic_Angel
Heiskanen and Dahlin got huge disrespected
Avs_Leafs_Enjoyer
Seider?? top ~~10~~20???
StatGAF
I’ve been saying for years, but they need to completely overhaul the ratings systems.
Right now, the scale is 36-99. But let’s be real, no one is really ever in the 30/40s. But they have to adjust so you have the CHL/Euro leagues which leaves 99% of NHLers between 80 and 90 with no real difference.
It would be great if they added scales so Shane Wright – for example, was a 90 in the OHL, an 84 in the AHL, and an 78 in the NHL. So if I put him on an OHL team, he gets a ratings spike but I move him to Seattle, and he goes down.
But I would also open up the ratings so like a 3rd pairing was a 60 overall vs. a 90 overall forward. So you dont need to put Mitch Marner’s checking rating at an 85 so he maintains a high overall or Carlson’s defensive rating at a 90
hairycookies
I really don’t like seeing EA NHL content on this sub.
mattfromjoisey
No Leafs, definitely an accurate list.
cubanpajamas
Still no Oilers. No surprise here, though Nuge really should have been on the LW list. We should have a couple at centre, though right? Right? Lol, watch them leave off Drai.
PieEatingJabroni1
A player with 1 season rated higher then Morgan Rielly. Ok.
BrokenEnigma-
Petro and Theo ☺️
avmp629
Slavin and Heiskanen are way too low, and I’d probably put Fox ahead of McAvoy
Constant-Squirrel555
Chabot isn’t even the best LD on his own team based off last season.
If he gets back to 55pt form, Ottawa is beyond set
Holiday_Use_2980
Miro and Slavin too low, while Carlson is too high
One-Management3649
No Tyler Myers?
Blagurtha
Confused as to why seider isn’t 100
hippiehs
Where is my man Spurgeon. Really think he is better than a couple of the RD guys
Shiny_Mew76
Swap Josi and Slavin
NowFook
Not that bad. Id move Fox over McAvoy and Carlsson probably out of the list.
FlapjackFiddle
Rielly isn’t even a top 10 LD???
Dudes literally point per game in his last two playoff runs LMAO 7G 11A in 18GP
Edit: How the fuck is Thomas Chabot higher 😂😂
TheNewPlague666
Seider finally getting some recognition. Dude is gonna be a beast in the coming years.
TealMadSus
Makar is so overrated it’s awful lol
VVG8
Anyone else bothered by the fact that the RD are in the left pic and the LD are in the right?
44 Comments
Surprised they think EK65 is 3 overall worse then Josi after just winning the Norris and putting up 100 points
slavin too low as usual
Carlson and Hedman little too high
Miro is too low
Charlie Mac > Fox…? Okay?
I’d have Sanderson over Chabot, but either way it’s awesome to see a Sen in the top 10 of something
Interesting choice there with Carlson
Carlson is a bit high here lol. Maybe an 88 due to his offensive capabilities but he’s awful defensively.
I still want Toews back
Bunch of geeks trying to rank athletes. Hit the gym, dorks
Hampus Lindholm better
Charlie Mac best in the game
Chabot is wayyyyy to high. He’s the third best defenceman on Ottawa
I’ll take Petro. Not much he can’t do when it’s playoff time.
I haven’t played a hockey videogame in almost 20 years, so I apologize if this is a stupid question, but: why the differentiation between left and right defensemen? Does the game treat them as if they are totally different positions? Like you can’t pair Karlsson and Letang up because they’re both right defensemen?
Fascinating, but Theodore lines up on the right more than he lines up on the left.
Has Josi had a late career resurgence? Obviously he was always good, but the last 2-3 seem to be a second peak for him
Devon Toews not being on this list is absolutely stupid.
Edit: still not used to this shit official reddit app. The little dots indicating a second photo are fucking tiny. I see it now. The lime green eye cancer background doesn’t help either.
Disrespect to Miro is very very very real.
These are always good for a chuckle.
Seider has had a great start to his career but 88 already is a bit much
I’m sorry but I think Roman Josi gets overrated a lot. Like he’s no doubt a #1 defenseman but I don’t think he’s ahead of a lot of these guys under him. I’d give him a 90 instead of a 94.
Chabot is lowkey overrated by EA and I am a Sens Fan. Sanderson is just better or tied with Chabby imo
Roman Josi is NOT that good holy cow
Heiskanen and Dahlin got huge disrespected
Seider?? top ~~10~~20???
I’ve been saying for years, but they need to completely overhaul the ratings systems.
Right now, the scale is 36-99. But let’s be real, no one is really ever in the 30/40s. But they have to adjust so you have the CHL/Euro leagues which leaves 99% of NHLers between 80 and 90 with no real difference.
It would be great if they added scales so Shane Wright – for example, was a 90 in the OHL, an 84 in the AHL, and an 78 in the NHL. So if I put him on an OHL team, he gets a ratings spike but I move him to Seattle, and he goes down.
But I would also open up the ratings so like a 3rd pairing was a 60 overall vs. a 90 overall forward. So you dont need to put Mitch Marner’s checking rating at an 85 so he maintains a high overall or Carlson’s defensive rating at a 90
I really don’t like seeing EA NHL content on this sub.
No Leafs, definitely an accurate list.
Still no Oilers. No surprise here, though Nuge really should have been on the LW list. We should have a couple at centre, though right? Right? Lol, watch them leave off Drai.
A player with 1 season rated higher then Morgan Rielly. Ok.
Petro and Theo ☺️
Slavin and Heiskanen are way too low, and I’d probably put Fox ahead of McAvoy
Chabot isn’t even the best LD on his own team based off last season.
If he gets back to 55pt form, Ottawa is beyond set
Miro and Slavin too low, while Carlson is too high
No Tyler Myers?
Confused as to why seider isn’t 100
Where is my man Spurgeon. Really think he is better than a couple of the RD guys
Swap Josi and Slavin
Not that bad. Id move Fox over McAvoy and Carlsson probably out of the list.
Rielly isn’t even a top 10 LD???
Dudes literally point per game in his last two playoff runs LMAO 7G 11A in 18GP
Edit: How the fuck is Thomas Chabot higher 😂😂
Seider finally getting some recognition. Dude is gonna be a beast in the coming years.
Makar is so overrated it’s awful lol
Anyone else bothered by the fact that the RD are in the left pic and the LD are in the right?