Hmmm tough decision, but I’d have to go with llundqvist just cause of his consistency and staying healthy
RangersGoalieFanClub
Henrik Lundqvist 🥹
SnarkyMarsupial7
I’d prefer Peter Sidorkiewicz
jarpio
I love Carey Price but the answer is Hank. No disrespect to Bobby Lu either, Fucking great goalie.
If Hank and Price are the 2000s-2010s version of Brodeur and Roy, Lu is probably Belfour or Cujo. That’s kinda how I break them down in my mind (not saying they are or aren’t as good as any of those guys, just an example)
realistthoughts
It’d have to be the King.
minos157
Build a franchise around Luongo or trade him and Jokinen for Parrish and Kvasha because he looked at an apartment on gameday?
​
Millbury challenge level impossible.
habulous74
Obviously Price because he was easily and by far the best tender of the three and it’s not close.
burnittodust
One need only look at the numbers, it’s Price!!
FLA-Hoosier
Give me prime Lu. G
Odd-Elderberry-6137
King Henry. No hesitation.
QuietInstruction8210
The King and I’ll build team and a band.
Ramulus14
As an oilers fan, what are these things?
Sakic_Fan_22
#30, HENRIK LUNDQVIST!
ReTep481
As much as I want to say Carey Price, he has a tendency to be injured far too often and for too long. Henrik Lundqvist is definitely my pick.
Dank_Bubu
I remember a survey that concluded Price was the most feared goalie among players. So yeah, him
WillNotBeSilenxed
Luongo, long career, Vezina candidate still in the twilight of his career. Was robbed of a Vezina… I believe that if Chicago had a goalie like Lu they would’ve went 5 for 6 in that dynasty period.
Otterslayer22
Hank. Just for the hair alone.
Traditional_Bee_6637
Of these 3. I’d say Hank I think.
Arfguy
Price, without question.
rideronthestorm29
CP for sure
Aboberg
Has to be Mr. Schampoo, Henrik Lundqvist
Tireseas
Hank, but the margin basically comes down to liking his style. All three are great.
GovernmentHunting016
It’s Hank and there’s no real argument for anyone else
Non-Vanilla_Zilla
None cause they’re all retired.
ItzGrenier
Price absolutely put an entire franchise on his back, Hank nor Lu can say the same as they both had good teams in front of them.
CallMeTeff
As a Habs fan, I loved Price but I have to choose Lundqvist.
Straight-Plate-5256
Probably none as they’re all retired and getting up there in age…
Mr_Hamster01
Carey Price just cause I got to watch his WHL career, if my heart chooses. If my brain is choosing then Lundy cause he was just consistent and you knew he’d be there when you needed him.
tecate_papi
Price. The guy did a Hasek and, as a goalie, dragged a bad team to the Stanley Cup Finals. If he had at least one guy good enough to play offence he might have pulled it off.
YugeFrigginGoy
Price, hands down. The man struck fear, and consistently.
Tola76
I like that you picked the three goalies teams tried to build around and failed.
… Lundqvist (sp?).
rickyspanish895
The sad thing is none of these goalies have Stanley cup rings.
Most-Iron6838
Carey price carried inferior team to cup finals
3pieceSuit
Makes me sad none of these guys got a cup.
CookieMonsta1771
Carey fucking Price all day everyday. The PRICE is right bitch!
gars_random
Carey!
gid_hola
Can’t believe so many are picking anyone other than price. Dude carried the franchise for years.
tduff714
I’m taking Price even though I love Lu and King Henry too. My heart still belongs to Flower though, really wish we could have kept him
Business-Broccoli331
I’d say Price. I’m a Leafs fan, but he was just absolutely clutch. He always seem to get injured too and played really well despite that.
Old_Cryptographer226
Price had the highest highs but Luongo was the most consistently good goalie for the long period of time out of all of them
AmeriCanadian98
Price or Hank. No disrespect to BobbyLou, I just think he’s a step behind those 2 (who are imo the best goalies of the last gen of goalies)
Dennyg818
Price duhhh
big-ole-kuck
Considering Price carried the habs deep in the playoffs multiple times without any 100+ point scorers and no real other offensive weapons during his time I’d say Price
Ailibis
Brodeur….please bring him back.
*a NJD fan coping and seething*
GQMatthews
It’s always Carey Price. It will forever be Carey Price. Someone here said Hank cause of his health without realizing Price was extremely durable throughout his career. Kris Kreider doesn’t ruin his knee and Price would still be a top goaltender playing right now.
Ido_nothing
Price, best goalie of this generation imo and I don’t think it’s close. His peak was insane and he was on a mediocre/bad team his whole career and he made them playoff teams and even contenders at times.
Selmanella
Kiprusoff.
fatch0deBoi34
I know Lu had great longevity and some nice moments, but I feel like he always messed up in the biggest moments. Henrick or Price for me. Either works
49 Comments
Hmmm tough decision, but I’d have to go with llundqvist just cause of his consistency and staying healthy
Henrik Lundqvist 🥹
I’d prefer Peter Sidorkiewicz
I love Carey Price but the answer is Hank. No disrespect to Bobby Lu either, Fucking great goalie.
If Hank and Price are the 2000s-2010s version of Brodeur and Roy, Lu is probably Belfour or Cujo. That’s kinda how I break them down in my mind (not saying they are or aren’t as good as any of those guys, just an example)
It’d have to be the King.
Build a franchise around Luongo or trade him and Jokinen for Parrish and Kvasha because he looked at an apartment on gameday?
​
Millbury challenge level impossible.
Obviously Price because he was easily and by far the best tender of the three and it’s not close.
One need only look at the numbers, it’s Price!!
Give me prime Lu. G
King Henry. No hesitation.
The King and I’ll build team and a band.
As an oilers fan, what are these things?
#30, HENRIK LUNDQVIST!
As much as I want to say Carey Price, he has a tendency to be injured far too often and for too long. Henrik Lundqvist is definitely my pick.
I remember a survey that concluded Price was the most feared goalie among players. So yeah, him
Luongo, long career, Vezina candidate still in the twilight of his career. Was robbed of a Vezina… I believe that if Chicago had a goalie like Lu they would’ve went 5 for 6 in that dynasty period.
Hank. Just for the hair alone.
Of these 3. I’d say Hank I think.
Price, without question.
CP for sure
Has to be Mr. Schampoo, Henrik Lundqvist
Hank, but the margin basically comes down to liking his style. All three are great.
It’s Hank and there’s no real argument for anyone else
None cause they’re all retired.
Price absolutely put an entire franchise on his back, Hank nor Lu can say the same as they both had good teams in front of them.
As a Habs fan, I loved Price but I have to choose Lundqvist.
Probably none as they’re all retired and getting up there in age…
Carey Price just cause I got to watch his WHL career, if my heart chooses. If my brain is choosing then Lundy cause he was just consistent and you knew he’d be there when you needed him.
Price. The guy did a Hasek and, as a goalie, dragged a bad team to the Stanley Cup Finals. If he had at least one guy good enough to play offence he might have pulled it off.
Price, hands down. The man struck fear, and consistently.
I like that you picked the three goalies teams tried to build around and failed.
… Lundqvist (sp?).
The sad thing is none of these goalies have Stanley cup rings.
Carey price carried inferior team to cup finals
Makes me sad none of these guys got a cup.
Carey fucking Price all day everyday. The PRICE is right bitch!
Carey!
Can’t believe so many are picking anyone other than price. Dude carried the franchise for years.
I’m taking Price even though I love Lu and King Henry too. My heart still belongs to Flower though, really wish we could have kept him
I’d say Price. I’m a Leafs fan, but he was just absolutely clutch. He always seem to get injured too and played really well despite that.
Price had the highest highs but Luongo was the most consistently good goalie for the long period of time out of all of them
Price or Hank. No disrespect to BobbyLou, I just think he’s a step behind those 2 (who are imo the best goalies of the last gen of goalies)
Price duhhh
Considering Price carried the habs deep in the playoffs multiple times without any 100+ point scorers and no real other offensive weapons during his time I’d say Price
Brodeur….please bring him back.
*a NJD fan coping and seething*
It’s always Carey Price. It will forever be Carey Price. Someone here said Hank cause of his health without realizing Price was extremely durable throughout his career. Kris Kreider doesn’t ruin his knee and Price would still be a top goaltender playing right now.
Price, best goalie of this generation imo and I don’t think it’s close. His peak was insane and he was on a mediocre/bad team his whole career and he made them playoff teams and even contenders at times.
Kiprusoff.
I know Lu had great longevity and some nice moments, but I feel like he always messed up in the biggest moments. Henrick or Price for me. Either works
Henrik