Here are the players that Caps reddit has chosen so far
A: Alex Ovechkin
B: Peter Bondra
C: John Carlson
D: Devante Smith-Pelly
E: Evgeny Kuznetsov
F: Sergei Fedorov
G: Mike Gartner
DaniCapsFan
Braden Holtby. No contest.
Ok-Afternoon4262
Dale Hunter. #32 is in the rafters!
bryguy1234
Jeff halpern
brandeneast
I’d call it a recency bias but maybe it’s a success bias…sorry Hunter- it’s gotta be Holtby. The Save is bigger than the OT goal on Hextall.
DHVF
The Holtbeast!
Letsgocaps33
No cup without Holtby!
Crazywhatwhat
Hahah. Y’all messed up!!! Which of you is going to bench Holtby over Hunter? A Sophie’s choice in the making. My choice is Hunter makes the cut. If we could go back I would say DSP gets the short straw over Bondra if we are playing “what we should have done”
No_Maintenance_9608
Dale Hunter
CapsDrago7
Gotta be the Holtbeast. As good as Hunter was, you gotta give this to our cup winning goaltender
HereInTheCut
Another vote for Holtby.
SSM1228
Halpern. Since that’s when I really got into hockey. His first year. But Holtby otherwise.
One-Mission-4505
Hunter AND Holtby
PoundOk5924
Halpern easy
kockin26
Kevin Hatcher
CrashWV
Hunter greater than Holtby
Rddtmcrddtface
Holtby!
Ubechyahescores
Should be last names only
VBStrong_67
Braden Holtby.
Call it recency bias if you want, but there’s no cup without Holtby.
goodleaf6
Holtby obvious answer but shout-out to The Paralyzer, Matt Hendricks. Shootout god
MadFlava76
This one is going to be generational. For the older fans they will remember Dale Hunter with the “Goal” against the Flyers. Younger fans will only remember Holtby with the “Save” against Vegas.
strewnshank
Shoulda saved B for Holtby, H for Hunter, and given Bonzi the P. But too late! Gotta be Holtby based on the cup win, but poor Hunter because he’ll be out, which is insane. But it’s more insane to leave off the cup winning goalie.
DonChronleone
Halpern
MadFlava76
This was a tough one but I’m going with Holtby. Love Dave Hunter and I even have his jersey in my collection but Holtby a huge reason we finally won the cup.
AcceptableCan2784
One of my favorites, Matt Hendricks.
Senemish
Chris Hajt
ExplanationNo752
Roman Hamrlik, easy
2KBIR
Dale Hunter!!!
letters2nora
Holtbeast!
sawdust_84
Your option was D – Dale Hunter. H – Brayden Holtby.
rene_magritte
If it weren’t for the shame of the Turgeon assault, Hunter would be an acceptable choice. I’m going with Holtby.
CFHotBets
Holtby –
This is really tough for me between Hunter and Holts. But the cup breaks the tie for me. HOLTBEAST!
CFHotBets
MODIFICATION REQUEST!
Dale HUNTER should replace DSP at “D”. It’s no contest.
Like to get this changed!
PersimmonOver4503
Wat
CrunchyZebra
Should’ve been Dale Hunter over DSP. That said, Holtby all the way. Possibly the best tendy to ever play for this franchise and a large part of why we got the cup.
pinkglue99
Holts.
Helpful-Cod1422
Jeff Halpren
yawaworht128908
Bonsai to “P,” holtby to “B,” hunter at “H”
LebowskiVoodoo
If it ain’t Holtby I’m gonna riot.
So_Long_DentalPlan
Holtby
OrangeboyHD_
BRAYDEN HOLTBY
brownbagsurvivor
Caps legend Henrik Lundquist obviously
VF-41
Dale Hunter.
chucklas
Move Hunter to D and get rid of the nonsensical DSP pick and add Holtby to H. Problem solved.
44 Comments
Here are the players that Caps reddit has chosen so far
A: Alex Ovechkin
B: Peter Bondra
C: John Carlson
D: Devante Smith-Pelly
E: Evgeny Kuznetsov
F: Sergei Fedorov
G: Mike Gartner
Braden Holtby. No contest.
Dale Hunter. #32 is in the rafters!
Jeff halpern
I’d call it a recency bias but maybe it’s a success bias…sorry Hunter- it’s gotta be Holtby. The Save is bigger than the OT goal on Hextall.
The Holtbeast!
No cup without Holtby!
Hahah. Y’all messed up!!! Which of you is going to bench Holtby over Hunter? A Sophie’s choice in the making. My choice is Hunter makes the cut. If we could go back I would say DSP gets the short straw over Bondra if we are playing “what we should have done”
Dale Hunter
Gotta be the Holtbeast. As good as Hunter was, you gotta give this to our cup winning goaltender
Another vote for Holtby.
Halpern. Since that’s when I really got into hockey. His first year. But Holtby otherwise.
Hunter AND Holtby
Halpern easy
Kevin Hatcher
Hunter greater than Holtby
Holtby!
Should be last names only
Braden Holtby.
Call it recency bias if you want, but there’s no cup without Holtby.
Holtby obvious answer but shout-out to The Paralyzer, Matt Hendricks. Shootout god
This one is going to be generational. For the older fans they will remember Dale Hunter with the “Goal” against the Flyers. Younger fans will only remember Holtby with the “Save” against Vegas.
Shoulda saved B for Holtby, H for Hunter, and given Bonzi the P. But too late! Gotta be Holtby based on the cup win, but poor Hunter because he’ll be out, which is insane. But it’s more insane to leave off the cup winning goalie.
Halpern
This was a tough one but I’m going with Holtby. Love Dave Hunter and I even have his jersey in my collection but Holtby a huge reason we finally won the cup.
One of my favorites, Matt Hendricks.
Chris Hajt
Roman Hamrlik, easy
Dale Hunter!!!
Holtbeast!
Your option was D – Dale Hunter. H – Brayden Holtby.
If it weren’t for the shame of the Turgeon assault, Hunter would be an acceptable choice. I’m going with Holtby.
Holtby –
This is really tough for me between Hunter and Holts. But the cup breaks the tie for me. HOLTBEAST!
MODIFICATION REQUEST!
Dale HUNTER should replace DSP at “D”. It’s no contest.
Like to get this changed!
Wat
Should’ve been Dale Hunter over DSP. That said, Holtby all the way. Possibly the best tendy to ever play for this franchise and a large part of why we got the cup.
Holts.
Jeff Halpren
Bonsai to “P,” holtby to “B,” hunter at “H”
If it ain’t Holtby I’m gonna riot.
Holtby
BRAYDEN HOLTBY
Caps legend Henrik Lundquist obviously
Dale Hunter.
Move Hunter to D and get rid of the nonsensical DSP pick and add Holtby to H. Problem solved.