@Canadiens de Montréal

Matthew Tkachuk échangé en Floride dans le cadre d’un accord à succès | Analyse instantanée avec @SteveDangle



Steve Dangle décompose l’accord à succès entre les Flames de Calgary et les Panthers de la Floride qui a envoyé Matthew Tkachuk à South Beach en échange de Jonathan Huberdeau, MacKenzie Weeger et plus. Selon vous, qui a remporté l’échange ? Faites-nous savoir dans les commentaires ci-dessous! ———————————————- Abonnez-vous à Sportsnet sur YouTube – http://sprtsnt.ca/2paAT2L Visitez Sportsnet.ca pour plus d’actualités sportives et de faits saillants – http://www.sportsnet.ca Suivez Sportsnet sur Facebook – http://sprtsnt.ca/YTFB Suivez Sportsnet sur Twitter – http://sprtsnt.ca/YTTWTR Suivez Sportsnet sur Instagram – http://sprtsnt.ca/YTINST Suivez Sportsnet sur Snapchat – http://sprtsnt.ca/YTSNAP Regardez Sportsnet sur Sportsnet maintenant – http://sportsnet.ca /à présent

40 Comments

  1. As a life long die hard Buffalo Sabres fan, old enough (sadly…LOL), to have cheered through both Sabres trips to the Finals in 1975 and 1999, watching them lose both in 6 games to the Flyers then the Stars, I have two answers to who won this trade. At my advanced current age, I’m frankly sick and tired of “building through the teenager draft” philosophy that has stunted the Sabres through 11 consecutive playoff-less seasons. As with my beloved Bills winning just one SB, I only want to see the Sabres win ONE Stanley Cup. Calgary is the huge winner of this trade based on my current feelings. I’m certainly not a Flames fan however they should use more of that cap space to sign a few more good players, trade a couple of those excess defensemen for good players and go for the Cup this season with Huberdeau and Weegar not being traded at all.

    If, however, like with so many of my fellow mostly younger Sabres fans seem to be, the Flames management & fans are fine and dandy with the long term re-build to win later philosophy then Calgary STILL wins this trade. They can move both guys out for more younger assets even before this season begins. I think that would suck for Flames fans but again, that’s just me. The Panthers? They basically just broke even getting Thackuk for Huberdeau. Florida lost this trade. ..unless of course Thackuk scores the winning goal in OT of the 7th game of the Finals against the Flames, of course.

  2. Flames won simply because they received more talent, without regard to where those players wind up. Plus, my understanding is that Tkachuk is a hard personality to deal with… meaning he's one step away from a locker room cancer. If he rolls in thinking he's a king, the Cats will be a sinking ship.

  3. You can't blame these guys for wanting out of Canada. I feel bad for Huberdeau. He will not stay long; the taxes alone will be enough for him to say see ya Canada. 2 million in taxes or something like that.

  4. SAVE THE STATE OF FLORIDA: Demand that Zack Kassian gets traded to Tampa Bay to keep that little pest Tkachuk in his place

  5. Huberdeau and Weegar either sign extensions or they get flipped again. So even if they don't want to stay it's not the end of the world, Huberdeau in particular will bring a huge deadline haul. I don't necessarily count Calgary out of signing Kadri either. Kadri didn't say he didn't want to go to Calgary he said he refused the trade because he wanted more time to try and figure out staying where he was.

  6. Too many distractions in Florida especially for a guy coming from Calgary. Nothing to do but focus on hockey in Calgary. Calgary wins.

  7. I hope the Flames move Mangiapane to the first line with Huberdeau. My opinion this would be ab better line than last years.

  8. Tkachuck's younger and possesses an equal if not better skillset. plus the contract length. WIN for Florida. for once.

  9. Having digested it the past couple of days, I'm feeling really good about this trade. Go Panthers!

  10. It will be one heck of trade tree in a few years when the Flames can't re-sign Weegs & Huby and shop them to MTL or something. If the Cats win a Cup, they win.

  11. Flames win hands down as long as they either resign both or at least get market value for both at the deadline.

  12. How is it a debate? The flames traded a 4th round pick and guy who wouldn't sign, for two guys who MIGHT not sign, and a prospect, and a first round pick… Am I missing something?

  13. The Ottawa senators trade for cat from the Chicago Blackhawks who will become a free agent next year unless we give him an extension Plus we have the addition of giroux

  14. On the surface, it looks like the Panthers lost this deal. But, then, I got to thinking: Panthers may have been the deepest team talent-wise prior to the trade, they will be fine. They will not have to sign Hubie to a 10M a year contract in 2023 and do get a goal scorer to complement Barkov (remember him?). Panthers do need to get more defensive help now but, with our management, I have good hopes that they will.

  15. Calgary has replaced Gaudreau, but not Tkachuk. If they don't sign Kadri, they are weaker.

  16. Why would a francophone play in a city and province that hates Quebec? I've lived in Alberta. If you tell me that's not true you are full of crap.

  17. Brad would become the Team President not be fired because his dad owns part of the team.

  18. Thing is Calgary still need a real head couch.. Sutter can’t do it an players don’t want to play for Sutter as he throws them under the bus to save is own azzzzzzz every time

  19. Kylington Signed, Huberdeau Signed And now Tack on Kadri Signing oh i think this teams going to be a threat this year

  20. It's interesting to watch this a month after it happened… especially since Huberdeau has signed long term, Monohan has been traded and Kadri has signed.

  21. Did this really happen?? MT one of the best all around forwards in the league. Sandpaper who can score

  22. Florida got absolutely fleeced on this I'm shocked nobody is framing it like that. Maybe they are but I never use twitter so, who knows.

  23. This is the most insane trade I have ever seen in my 15-20 years of following the National Hockey League.

Write A Comment

Pin