J’ai recréé les Red Wings de 2011 (ma première année en tant qu’amateur de hockey). Comment ai-je fait? Qui est noté trop bas et trop haut ?
—
Dev_NT
@Red Wings de Détroit
J’ai recréé les Red Wings de 2011 (ma première année en tant qu’amateur de hockey). Comment ai-je fait? Qui est noté trop bas et trop haut ?
—
Dev_NT
26 Comments
Also RIP Ruslan Salei
Ericsson should be 99 OVR
This reminded me of Hollands fascination with Bertuzzi
This is cool, and congrats on joining the fandom. I would probably reference NHL 11 or 12 and see what the ratings were (or maybe a fan made 2011 roster file since people dislike EA’s ratings so much)
https://preview.redd.it/9a0dy02cf2na1.jpeg?width=750&format=pjpg&auto=webp&v=enabled&s=4cc1f83b023af8d99370e2b5d17c1386a226b93c
From an Xbox 360 forum 12 years ago haha; looks like you are all around pretty close except they didn’t value Lidstrom as highly
Pav, Hank, and Franzenstein are probably accurate. The others are way high, especially the 4th line.
Lidstrom should be 99 and Kronwall was better than Rafalski
That D core
Abdekader is about 80 points too high.
Franzen one point better than Cleary? The fuck is this? Lol honestly a lot of ratings seem…disproportionate? Idk man I haven’t picked up a chel game in a minute so I’m not sure how they are tanking anymore
hudler, helm, and the entire 4th line are way too high. ericsson and salei too high.
Hey! I became a fan in 2011 too. My very first game was against the Sharks on Game 6. The Wings lost the series on Game 7 but damn JLA crowd on Game 6 was unreal.
I miss Draper winding up for clappers from two steps outside the crease
I forgot we had Holmstrom at that point
What’s everyone’s view of abvelkader I didn’t watch much when he was around
This was my peak Wings fan year (I was SO obsessed) and holy shit some of these names are such a flashback.
Zetterberg should be at least a 91/92
Ericsson that frickin scrub
Put some respect on Saleis name!
Bertuzzi made his NHL debut in 2016; he shouldn’t be on this team.
Swap D and Z and you’re good.
Draper an 80? Howard should be 20 points lower. And lose more points for his current career.
Id say this was perfect for reminding me how wrong i was in thinking Jimmy Howard and Jonathan Ericsson were going to be the next Red Wing Superstars to build the team around
I’d add one more notch to Lidstrom and Datsyuk
Datsyuk 95
Zetterberg 91
Filppula 84
Draper 80
Holmstrom 80
Hudler 83
Bertuzzi 84
Franzen 86
Cleary 83
Eaves 79
Helm 80
Lidstrom 97
Rafalski 88
Kronwall 86
Stuart 85
Ericsson 80
Salei 79
Howard 82
MacDonald 78
This just triggered my everlasting annoyance at Babcock’s absolute conviction to keep Pav and Hank separated. We had the depth, and we were always better when they were kept on the same line.
Sorry, I didn’t mean to go off topic.
If Abdelkader isn’t -81 he’s too high.