Salut les amis,
Nous sommes très heureux d’annoncer une AMA aujourd’hui à 15 h HE avec David St-Louis, analyste de hockey et rédacteur d’espoirs pour Elite Prospects. Je suis sûr que beaucoup d’entre vous connaissent son travail exceptionnel.
Le guide du repêchage EP 2024 de la LNH (Wallet payant)
Analyse vidéo : Ivan Demidov est un joueur comme vous ne l’avez jamais vu auparavant
N’hésitez pas à lui poser des questions en anglais ET en français concernant les espoirs du Tricolore et les espoirs éligibles au prochain repêchage de la LNH.
Nous sommes reconnaissants à David d’être revenu pour faire une autre AMA cette année avant le repêchage de la LNH, alors souhaitons-lui la bienvenue à nouveau dans la communauté.
—
Go_Habs_Go31
23 Comments
Salut David!
Je me demandais à quel point ton approche change au fil des ans considérant que année après année tu fais des prédictions sur le futures de plusieurs joueurs, certain tu avais raison et d’autre non. A partir de combien de « miss » tu commences a revoir ta méthodologie ou bien la valeur donner a certain trait d’un joueur et aussi en général qu’est-ce que tu dirais qui a le plus changé dans ta manière d’évaluer des joueurs depuis tes débuts.
Merci!
Who’s your favourite under the radar prospect and why?
How much do you think Lindstrom is being propped up by good line mates?
Hi David, thanks for this!
Hope you don’t mind a dive into some revisionist history.
If you could choose Leonard/Parekh or Reinbacher/Iginla to add to your team, which duo would you pick?
Hi David! I love your work, especially your video breakdowns.
Question: Who are two prospects you were wrong about? One who is better than you expected and one who didn’t pan out as you predicted.
Thanks!
Hello there! Thanks for this, your draft guide is awsome btw. So, do you think about Justin Porier? Good idea to take him with our late second or the third?
why do u think eiserman’s draft value has fallen off so much? many ppl suggest it is bc he is very one-dimensional, but the habs are in need of a “shoot first” type of player. do u think martin st. louis can turn him into a more well rounded player like how he has done so with caufield? iirc caufield was also touted as a one-dimensional sniper when he was first drafted and he has developed his 2-way game quite dramatically over the past season. do u think it would be worth it to trade up in the draft using the WPG pick to acquire eiserman? or do u not see him as a valuable pick?
Hey David,
With the fifth overall pick this year the habs are obviously leaning towards a forward, and while people have been debating Demidov, Lindstrom and even Iginla, I wonder why Berkly Catton seems to be left out of the conversation sometimes. From watching him his playstyle seems to fit the need of a dynamic offensive threat and his numbers are extremely impressive. Are there any risks in taking a player like Catton? Is there something that we are missing that leads to him falling down some draft boards?
Thanks!
if demidov is gone at 5, between lindstrom and sennecke, which do u think would better fit the habs current roster and which do u project would have a higher ceiling? how would u compare the two?
Hi David, How would you compare Iginla to Leonard last year?
Also saw on the draft guide (which is fantastic) you all have Iginla a fair few spots higher than Sennecke. Do you think it would be a mistake if Sennecke was the pick at 5 over Iginla?
Hi David!
You often use the reasoning that many smaller defensman who struggle to defend have failed in the NHL recently, using the example of guys like Brannstrom, to bump down a guy like Alfons Freij for example. Why doesn’t that same standard apply to Zayne Parekh, ranked 6th by EP? Thanks!
(Also btw there’s an error in the draft guide the linus eriksson write-up is just a copy paste of the lucas pettersson write-up. Just so someone knows!)
Hi David,
Which unexpected prospect in the Draft Habs fans should be keeping an eye on, which we may have missed due to looking at usual names?
Salut David,
Est-ce qu’il y a des joueurs qui ont un plafond plus élevé que les gens pensent et qui pourraient devenir vraiment dominants? Par exemple, un hars projeté en milieu ou en fin de ronde qui pourrait être top 5 dans un redraft dans 5 ou 10 ans; bref, des coups de circuit si les astres sont alignés?
De l’autre côté de la médaille, parmi les joueurs projetés en première ronde, lesquels sont les plus susceptibles de ne jamais avoir d’impact dans la LNH, et de chuter dans un éventuel redraft?
C’est pas évident comme question parce que ça demande de faire de la projection et beaucoup de suppositions, mais je suis curieux de savoir si des noms te viennent en tête?
Merci!
pronman of the Athletic has doubled down on demidov falling to 5, how likely do u think this is to happen in a D-heavy draft?
based on chicago, anaheim, and columbus’ current organizational needs, do u believe that any of those teams would actually pass up on him? or is it just a pipe dream?
Thanks David.
Of these main attributes measured:
**Skating – Shooting – Passing – Puckhandling – Hockey IQ – Physicality**
Which is the attribute(or which combinations) most important in the NHL and why?
who would u say of the top prospects (excluding celebrini and demidov) would u say has the highest ceiling? who has the highest floor? are there any prospects within that group that u deem as “boom or bust”?
personally i have my doubts about silayev, do u think that many ppl are overrating him due to his height? would he be another tyler myers? or is he more skilled?
Hey David I was wondering what’s the thought process in evaluating someone like Sennecke. He had such a weird season both production wise, but also with his growth spurts and all. How do you rank someone who has clear potentials but is unclear wether he can put everything together and could easily bust?
Salut David! Je me souviens (ignore moi si je me trompe) que tu était un »fan » de Norlinder après le camp qui nous a fait et son temps en Europe (Comme beaucoup d’autre et moi y compris). Je ne sais pas à quel point tu suis les espoires après leur repêchage, mais qu’est ce que tu pense qui est arrivé dans son cas? Est-ce que le problème est au niveau de son développement, ou est-ce qu’il y a raison de penser que nous n’avions pas une vision assez globale de son jeu puisqu’il jouait en Europe?
Hi David,
Who do you think is the better prospect between Demidov and Michkov?
Salut David, merci de prendre le temps de faire ce AMA! J’aimerais avoir ton opinion sur la raison de la descente de Catton? Je suis un fan de lui et ne comprends pas pourquoi il n’est pas dans la discussion au 5e rang, lui qui est d’ailleurs au moins aussi gros que les Point, Hughes et Kucherov?
Any updated thoughts on Joshua Roy after his NHL sample? If you were to give his 23 games a Letter Grade what would it be and what would you put as notes on his report card?
What prospects in the late first would you like to see the Habs draft? I follow the top end but haven’t heard much about the second half of the 1st round
Hi David,
Do you think Iginla is being overlooked as a possible top 5 or 6 pick? His under 18 performance and season overall were quite impressive and seems like he has all the tools of a 40+ goal scorer.