Maintenant que nous avons dépassé le repêchage et l’agence libre, il est temps de passer à l’annuelle /r/DetroitRedWings Fil de discussion sur le classement des espoirs ! Quant à la manière dont vous votez, c’est entièrement à vous de décider : certains peuvent accorder la plus grande importance au plafond ou à la hausse, d’autres peuvent accorder une plus grande importance à la préparation à la LNH – il n’y a pas de mauvaise réponse sur la façon de voter.
Un nouveau sondage sera publié tous les 2-3 jours en fonction de la proximité du vote jusqu’à ce que nous ayons terminé avec les 15 meilleurs prospects. J’inclurai 10~ prospects à chaque sondage et j’ajouterai un nouveau prospect après chaque sondage, alors discutez-en dans les commentaires et celui qui sera le plus mentionné sera ajouté ensuite.
Consultez les classements précédents du subreddit ici (à partir de 2018 !) : LIEN ICI
REMARQUES:
– Les critères de prospection seront définis à l’aide de Lignes directrices de la LNH.
– Après les classements de la saison dernière, un sondage a été réalisé pour déterminer s’il fallait ou non afficher les résultats du sondage. Continuer à masquer les résultats entre les sondages a donné lieu à plus de votes.
#1. Nate Danielson (C – 2023 #9) – 61% des 731 votes [Results]
#2. Axel Sandin-Pellikka (RD – 2023 #17) – 58% des 658 voix [Results]
#3. Sebastian Cossa (G – 2021 #15) – 52% des 635 votes [Results]
—
SimplySolace
![[Results]](https://i.imgur.com/ouJTyie.png){kind=link}
![[Results]](https://i.imgur.com/45mbzYC.png){kind=link}
![[Results]](https://i.imgur.com/rKwMZYv.png){kind=link}
7 Comments
Kasper next and I don’t think it’s very close, honestly. Augustine would be my guess for 5th. After that, I think we’ve left our 1st tier prospect pool and gotten into our tier of very very good.
To me this is where things start to get difficult. I think the first three prospects were easy because they are a cut or two above the rest. For number 4 I can convince myself to go a few different directions. I went with Kasper because I think his floor is certain NHLer. I think there are options with more upside, though.
Voted MBN last round. Going with him until he is gone as he has the highest upside, but still a secure floor, IMO.
I think Kasper/Augustine are the next 2
Then we can start talking MBN
I get that he gets the shiny new toy hype, but man do we have some guys whose mix of production and projection are better
Kasper was a better prospect at the time he was drafted, plays center and while I still question his ultimate offensive upside he still produced in the SHL in his draft year, something MBN hadn’t done
Then Augustine, anytime a teenager makes a WC roster for a major hockey country (not just out of necessity) and plays meaningful games then you know you have someone special
Kasper and MBN are close for me, but Kasper being a C and much closer to the NHL gives him a slight edge. Kinda think his all-around game will be a bit more valuable than MBN from the wing. Wouldn’t be upset if MBN takes it though.
At this point I’m voting for Kasper purely because he is the prospect I want to blow past his perceived ceiling the most. A skilled, fast and physical scoring forward that forechecks like hell, plays defensively responsible and fiddles his fingers into the befuddled faces of his opponents in scrums? Sign me up.
I voted MBN last time, but thought Cossa and Kasper were close. I’m fine with Cossa at #3 (I find it hard to rank goalies and project them, so I would have voted for him later).
Maybe I’m buying into shiny new toy hype, but I think MBN has a higher ceiling, so I’ll vote for him again, but wouldn’t disagree if the majority picks Kasper.