I was prepared to argue today that Hedman does in fact still belong in the top 10 but I didn’t want this, please be nice to him he didn’t ask to be used in this rage bait like this
Also Darren Raddysh snubbed
billyspectacles
Gotta be one of the worst of these types of lists I’ve seen.
reggiebobby
What metric are they using here? Lol this list is way off.
Micksar
Forsling is such a flash in the pan. Having him at 6 is wild.
JacktopherSnames
The disrespect for Fox
Key-Tip-7521
Fox not in top 5 is crazy
Showtime98
Fox at 8 is crazy lol, top 3-5 max. He is in my top 3.
wildlyintangible
Hanifin being top 20 is hilarious given that he was MAYBE Calgary’s third best dman last season and other years past. Yet, Ras and Weegar aren’t even on this list.
-TheNew11-
Ahhhh yes, Red Wings young gun Mortiz Seider
kingkellam
Fox is a top 3 defenseman in this league, come on.
tristan1616
Bouchard in the top 10 is insane. Dude puts up points because McDrai constantly feeds him them but he’s really not great defensively
Slice_Of_Life_DM
Reminder that these lists are only made to drive engagement
avmp629
It’s pretty crazy that Erik Karlsson won the Norris in 2023 and now he isn’t even in the top 20. I’d go as far as to say he was still pretty damn good this year with Pittsburgh, much fewer points but still a top-pair D
nothing_but_static
>Dobson at 15
A little low but I like
>Toews at 10
Pain
Ok_Championship3262
Where does Dahlin rank?
kinglywy
Forsling at 6 is actually absurd.
ACMop
Hedman is my favourite blueliner of all time and I still think he’s an elite blueliner, but the last days Hedman was top 3 were in 2022
The-dopechaud
Mortiz Seider 😭
The_guy_who_did_that
Hedman at 3 and fox at 8? Was that a mistake?
BillyNoMates12
Obvious bias will come through here but I do think Cale is the best Dman in the league. He isn’t just offense. He can play defense very well. Fox not being top 3 is laughable though
SiidChawsby
Dahlin placement is slander
SkittlesManiac19
Hedman at 3 is interesting
shig-baq
Fox is 100% top 3 at the lowest. 8 is blasphemy
Ant-man-2048
Forsling has to be the most overrated player in the NHL now.
He’s not better than Adam Fox. Dumb list.
Rangerboy030
P8 for Fox is taking the piss.
Bruins01
Forsling speed running from most underrated to most overrated
topbuttsteak
Foxy any lower than 3 is absolutely bonkers
tonyontherigs
Sorry, hedman is above WHO
moebuttermaker
Dougie Hamilton way too low. Hedman way too high at this point in his career. Noah Hanifin makes the list impossible to take seriously.
WadeReddit06
Bouchard and Fox need more love
Overall_Walrus_4853
I absolutely love Forsling and think that in the grand scheme of things he is underrated but this is a bit much. I put him in a similar range to Morrissey/Slavin and I suspect many (if not most) folks would think that is overrating him. I think even most fellow Cats fans would be hard pressed to take him over Fox/McAvoy/Dahlin
Gluske
These lists blow
dangertom69
This list is absolutely garbage. In a single year Forsling went from underrated to…whatever this is.
1RLegend
Dang seth jones didn’t make it again rats
CaseIHAvs
I thought the top four was pretty easy for anyone. Makar, Hughes, Fox, Heiskanen… boy was I wrong
Expert-Lock-6751
Fox at #8 is a joke. Not #1 but no worse than #4.
TildeGunderson
Forsling at 6 is nuts. I love him and he’s great, but compared to others, he’s in the 11-20, easy. Swapping him for Dahlin’s an easy choice, and even at 11, I’m not sure I’d put him above Slavin or Morrissey.
Also, Fox at 8? Sure thing, bud.
weschester
Noah Hanifin doesn’t show up on any top lists his entire time in Calgary but plays a few games in Vegas and is magically a top 20 D in the NHL? What a joke. Also Weegar is way better than him.
Birdhawk
Wow all of y’all are massively overvaluing Fox lol yikes.
thefailmaster19
Dahlin and Morrissey should be in the top 10, Hedman and Toews should be out (still top 15 though)
I know he had a down year but no Karlsson at all is wild
42 Comments
The disrespect to McIlrath
Fox not being top 3 is insane
I was prepared to argue today that Hedman does in fact still belong in the top 10 but I didn’t want this, please be nice to him he didn’t ask to be used in this rage bait like this
Also Darren Raddysh snubbed
Gotta be one of the worst of these types of lists I’ve seen.
What metric are they using here? Lol this list is way off.
Forsling is such a flash in the pan. Having him at 6 is wild.
The disrespect for Fox
Fox not in top 5 is crazy
Fox at 8 is crazy lol, top 3-5 max. He is in my top 3.
Hanifin being top 20 is hilarious given that he was MAYBE Calgary’s third best dman last season and other years past. Yet, Ras and Weegar aren’t even on this list.
Ahhhh yes, Red Wings young gun Mortiz Seider
Fox is a top 3 defenseman in this league, come on.
Bouchard in the top 10 is insane. Dude puts up points because McDrai constantly feeds him them but he’s really not great defensively
Reminder that these lists are only made to drive engagement
It’s pretty crazy that Erik Karlsson won the Norris in 2023 and now he isn’t even in the top 20. I’d go as far as to say he was still pretty damn good this year with Pittsburgh, much fewer points but still a top-pair D
>Dobson at 15
A little low but I like
>Toews at 10
Pain
Where does Dahlin rank?
Forsling at 6 is actually absurd.
Hedman is my favourite blueliner of all time and I still think he’s an elite blueliner, but the last days Hedman was top 3 were in 2022
Mortiz Seider 😭
Hedman at 3 and fox at 8? Was that a mistake?
Obvious bias will come through here but I do think Cale is the best Dman in the league. He isn’t just offense. He can play defense very well. Fox not being top 3 is laughable though
Dahlin placement is slander
Hedman at 3 is interesting
Fox is 100% top 3 at the lowest. 8 is blasphemy
Forsling has to be the most overrated player in the NHL now.
He’s not better than Adam Fox. Dumb list.
P8 for Fox is taking the piss.
Forsling speed running from most underrated to most overrated
Foxy any lower than 3 is absolutely bonkers
Sorry, hedman is above WHO
Dougie Hamilton way too low. Hedman way too high at this point in his career. Noah Hanifin makes the list impossible to take seriously.
Bouchard and Fox need more love
I absolutely love Forsling and think that in the grand scheme of things he is underrated but this is a bit much. I put him in a similar range to Morrissey/Slavin and I suspect many (if not most) folks would think that is overrating him. I think even most fellow Cats fans would be hard pressed to take him over Fox/McAvoy/Dahlin
These lists blow
This list is absolutely garbage. In a single year Forsling went from underrated to…whatever this is.
Dang seth jones didn’t make it again rats
I thought the top four was pretty easy for anyone. Makar, Hughes, Fox, Heiskanen… boy was I wrong
Fox at #8 is a joke. Not #1 but no worse than #4.
Forsling at 6 is nuts. I love him and he’s great, but compared to others, he’s in the 11-20, easy. Swapping him for Dahlin’s an easy choice, and even at 11, I’m not sure I’d put him above Slavin or Morrissey.
Also, Fox at 8? Sure thing, bud.
Noah Hanifin doesn’t show up on any top lists his entire time in Calgary but plays a few games in Vegas and is magically a top 20 D in the NHL? What a joke. Also Weegar is way better than him.
Wow all of y’all are massively overvaluing Fox lol yikes.
Dahlin and Morrissey should be in the top 10, Hedman and Toews should be out (still top 15 though)
I know he had a down year but no Karlsson at all is wild
Also who tf invited Hanifin