That’s a tough one. Gonna have to go with Hasek over Sawchuk and Osgood
ryerse
Best defender without lidstrom?? Best goalie: hasek
U5e4n4m3
Lyon, I guess, and Hasek for certain.
Tacoshirt5000
Hasek
HauckEck
Sawchuk – he had over 350 wins as a Red Wing.
redlion1904
It’s Sawchuk for all-time.
GrossePointeJayhawk
Terry Sawchuk and it’s not even close. The guy had records that weren’t broken until the 2000s and this was back when you only played like 50 games a season! He still holds the franchise records too.
SayNoToStim
After this sub putting Lidstrom > Howe I have no faith in them and thus expect Hasek to win this one.
But in reality it’s Sawchuk by a significant margin. This is the easiest square here.
For currently goalie it’s a fierce competition between « empty net » and the shooter tutor.
RedWingsForPresident
Sawchuk, Lyon
cooleyFit13
Vernon
cooleyFit13
The best should’ve been Gordie and Stevie.
Twizzlor
All-time is Sawchuk, hands down. There’s a reason he’s the only goalie to have his number retired by the Wings.
Flowsnice
Saw chuck
Inner_Internal7337
I love Dom. I have an Osgood sweater.
It’s Number One, hands down.
justin34berg
Sawchuk/lyon
jfstompers
Sawchuk, sure Hasek is the best but his best years weren’t here.
Bear_Bishop
Ozzie!
Fit_Mess4686
Howard is far from most under rated. He was terrible for the organization.
wazrok
Osgood
BiryaniBo
I understand the formality of the clarifying statement, but I don’t think we need to worry about Jimmy Howard stealing any votes here lol
rambored89
Sawchuk – all time
Current – talbot
ijster
Osgood!
ThatZenoGuy
Let me start by mentioning that Hasek is my favorite player of all time. However, Sawchuk should be the all-time goalie for the Wings. Sawchuk was amazing as a Wing and did a lot of his work as a Wing. Hasek was great for us, but he only spent 4 of his 16 years with us. While Sawchuk spent 14 of his 21 years with us, and he had his Hall of Fame waiting period waived because he was simply one of the greatest of all-time.
TL:DR Hasek and Sawchuk good, Sawchuk spent longer as Wing.
AmeriCanadian98
Sawchuk by a mile all time
Current is probably Talbot but of the goalies who have actually played a game for us I’d say Lyon
deadknees
Easily Sawchuk.
daveinthegutter
Best of all time sawchuk but personally ozzy, dependable, never a moment too big when we needed him
AmeriCanadian98
Howe should have won over lidstrom. He’s a mount Rushmore guy. He’s the second or 3rd best forward EVER.
I love Lidstrom, I have him firmly as the second best defenseman ever, but Howe should have won that. It’s bias towards a player that most of us got the pleasure of seeing play that he didn’t imo
DixieNorris
Obviously sawchuk but an absolute dark horse would be osgood in my opinion
smilingasIsay
All time Sawchuk, annnd current? I dunno. Roll a 7 sided die?
CopsPushMongo
2008 playoff legend Chris Osgood
Redditisabotfarm8
Ok but who is the best current goalie?
bestprocrastinator
I’m not sure that I love or hate the fact that the best goalie currently on this team is hard to answer
Many-Acanthaceae-296
Best goalie to ever wear Red wings jersey is Hasek, however the best Red Wings goalie (who played more seasons not just 4 like Hasek) has to be Sawchuk.
operaticsimplicity
Sawchuck, Ozzie
pavlinac
Current- Lyon
Areuuuserious
Current – Lyon
All time – Sawchuk
Wakattack00
Terry Sawchuk by an infinite amount. Then currently I guess Talbot.
jswitzer
Trick question – the only goaltender available for this is Sawchuk. The man racked up 350 wins with a SV% of 904! The only goalie to come anywhere close is Osgood and Osgood played after the CBA expansion to 82 games.
Baboshinu
All time is pretty easily Sawchuk. Hard to overstate how good he was.
Current I’d say Lyon. You could argue Talbot, but if we consider how good they’ve been with other teams then I’d have to change my all time to Hasek, and I’m not doing that, so I’ll stick with Lyon.
blochow2001
Terry Sawchuck hands down.
ChosenSwordsman
Ozzy was better than Howard imo.
ViconiaDevir
Terry Sawchuk, arguably the best goalie to ever take the ice, not just for the Red Wings.
Chemistry_Vibes1369
Terry Sawchuk
hockeypup
Ozzie
ltroberts24
All-Time: Terry Sawchuk
Current: Would it be wrong to say Sebastian Cossa or Trey Augustine?? If so, I’ll say Lyon since Talbot hasn’t played in the organization yet.
InfamousInvestment38
Ozzie for all time(I understand Sawchuck was great in his era but if u put prime Sawchuck in Ozzie’s timeline, he would not be good. The game is just different). And I promise I’m not trying to comment for shock value, but Trey Augustine is the best goalie in the org right now.
ape_on_a_rock
Overrated – Big Jonathan ‘No-trade clause’ ‘Pylon’ Ericsson
venk
I’m not 800 years old, so I’d go with the guy that won cups for us in multiple eras:
Ozy
unravleddonut
Sawchuk, Lyon
SkinnyMattFoley
Matta as underrated, and Rasmussen as overrated…… Then Mantha as most potential wasted, when his potential was/is LAZY. I’m out.
Ask the Capitals and Golden Knights how much potential that douchebag has. 🙄
50 Comments
That’s a tough one. Gonna have to go with Hasek over Sawchuk and Osgood
Best defender without lidstrom?? Best goalie: hasek
Lyon, I guess, and Hasek for certain.
Hasek
Sawchuk – he had over 350 wins as a Red Wing.
It’s Sawchuk for all-time.
Terry Sawchuk and it’s not even close. The guy had records that weren’t broken until the 2000s and this was back when you only played like 50 games a season! He still holds the franchise records too.
After this sub putting Lidstrom > Howe I have no faith in them and thus expect Hasek to win this one.
But in reality it’s Sawchuk by a significant margin. This is the easiest square here.
For currently goalie it’s a fierce competition between « empty net » and the shooter tutor.
Sawchuk, Lyon
Vernon
The best should’ve been Gordie and Stevie.
All-time is Sawchuk, hands down. There’s a reason he’s the only goalie to have his number retired by the Wings.
Saw chuck
I love Dom. I have an Osgood sweater.
It’s Number One, hands down.
Sawchuk/lyon
Sawchuk, sure Hasek is the best but his best years weren’t here.
Ozzie!
Howard is far from most under rated. He was terrible for the organization.
Osgood
I understand the formality of the clarifying statement, but I don’t think we need to worry about Jimmy Howard stealing any votes here lol
Sawchuk – all time
Current – talbot
Osgood!
Let me start by mentioning that Hasek is my favorite player of all time. However, Sawchuk should be the all-time goalie for the Wings. Sawchuk was amazing as a Wing and did a lot of his work as a Wing. Hasek was great for us, but he only spent 4 of his 16 years with us. While Sawchuk spent 14 of his 21 years with us, and he had his Hall of Fame waiting period waived because he was simply one of the greatest of all-time.
TL:DR Hasek and Sawchuk good, Sawchuk spent longer as Wing.
Sawchuk by a mile all time
Current is probably Talbot but of the goalies who have actually played a game for us I’d say Lyon
Easily Sawchuk.
Best of all time sawchuk but personally ozzy, dependable, never a moment too big when we needed him
Howe should have won over lidstrom. He’s a mount Rushmore guy. He’s the second or 3rd best forward EVER.
I love Lidstrom, I have him firmly as the second best defenseman ever, but Howe should have won that. It’s bias towards a player that most of us got the pleasure of seeing play that he didn’t imo
Obviously sawchuk but an absolute dark horse would be osgood in my opinion
All time Sawchuk, annnd current? I dunno. Roll a 7 sided die?
2008 playoff legend Chris Osgood
Ok but who is the best current goalie?
I’m not sure that I love or hate the fact that the best goalie currently on this team is hard to answer
Best goalie to ever wear Red wings jersey is Hasek, however the best Red Wings goalie (who played more seasons not just 4 like Hasek) has to be Sawchuk.
Sawchuck, Ozzie
Current- Lyon
Current – Lyon
All time – Sawchuk
Terry Sawchuk by an infinite amount. Then currently I guess Talbot.
Trick question – the only goaltender available for this is Sawchuk. The man racked up 350 wins with a SV% of 904! The only goalie to come anywhere close is Osgood and Osgood played after the CBA expansion to 82 games.
All time is pretty easily Sawchuk. Hard to overstate how good he was.
Current I’d say Lyon. You could argue Talbot, but if we consider how good they’ve been with other teams then I’d have to change my all time to Hasek, and I’m not doing that, so I’ll stick with Lyon.
Terry Sawchuck hands down.
Ozzy was better than Howard imo.
Terry Sawchuk, arguably the best goalie to ever take the ice, not just for the Red Wings.
Terry Sawchuk
Ozzie
All-Time: Terry Sawchuk
Current: Would it be wrong to say Sebastian Cossa or Trey Augustine?? If so, I’ll say Lyon since Talbot hasn’t played in the organization yet.
Ozzie for all time(I understand Sawchuck was great in his era but if u put prime Sawchuck in Ozzie’s timeline, he would not be good. The game is just different). And I promise I’m not trying to comment for shock value, but Trey Augustine is the best goalie in the org right now.
Overrated – Big Jonathan ‘No-trade clause’ ‘Pylon’ Ericsson
I’m not 800 years old, so I’d go with the guy that won cups for us in multiple eras:
Ozy
Sawchuk, Lyon
Matta as underrated, and Rasmussen as overrated…… Then Mantha as most potential wasted, when his potential was/is LAZY. I’m out.
Ask the Capitals and Golden Knights how much potential that douchebag has. 🙄